Jump to content


- - - - -

U2Fanz U22 Review



There are two conflicting things going on here for mine.

The first is track selection. On the release of U2's "Best Of's" there was always great debate about which songs were selected and which were not. The 80's compilation was probably a little too hit laden, but an accurate reflection of the bands work in the 80's. However, the 90's release wasn't as good a reflection of U2's most ambitious decade. I always thought it took the safe route after the back lash of Pop. More than once I thought I could do better, making sure more ambitious and important material like The Fly, Lemon and Mofo were included. You see, I know better! In more recent times, this type of debate has moved to Internet forums from almost every corner of the globe. Fans putting forward their suggestions for set-lists in the lead up to opening night of tours. We've all seen them: why not forget Pride and New Year's Day and open the show with Acrobat followed by Lady with the Spinning Head? Sound familiar? You see, we ALL know better. We should pick the set-list!

Secondly, as Bono will tell you, the sum is, when U2 is at its best, bigger than the parts. U2 concerts for many of us are a living breathing thing, merging 22-24 tracks into one big, loud and passionate celebration/experience. Think Red Rocks. Think Zoo TV Live in Sydney. Think post September 11 shows in New York. For that reason, U2's tour related releases are usually documented from a single show that illustrates this almost unrivaled skill. U2 are the best at this and a compilation CD will surely lose this? I never liked INXS Live Baby Live CD, for instance, as unlike the fantastic Wembley only video release, the CD was a mish-mash from several concerts on the tour; it just didn't work as well.

So here we are with U22, a fan voted fan club release so WE can select the best songs of the tour. Great idea, but will it be a cohesive document of the tour? Will it work? Does it matter?

Enough of that for the time being, it is all about the songs we picked. Can you think of a U2 live release that sounds better both technically (well done Declan/Joe) and performance wise? It sounds awesome and illustrates that despite advancing years, U2 still sound GREAT. The version of Bad, for instance, reaffirmed what I thought when we were lucky enough to hear it played in Melbourne and Sydney on 360. I left those shows thinking they were the best versions of Bad EVER, but put that down to after-concert glow. But you know what? They were playing Bad really well on 360 and this stunning version from Rome surely proves it. The segue into All I Want is You is fabulous, but does make the next track, All I Want is You, jar a little! But hell, we were there when they played All I Want is You/Love Rescue Me - and the thrilling two minute Michael Hutchence tribute in-between made this Australian spine tingle.

From the storming start of the re-imagined Even Better Than the Real Thing from Mexico, to the Frank Sinatra tinged Until the End of The World, it is a strong fast paced start. There are great performances perfectly mixed everywhere. I Still Haven't Found What I'm Looking For and Stay change the mood, both showing Bono's pipes still work. The fans know their stuff, why wouldn't U2 play Stay every night after hearing this? I suspect nearly everyone voted for One Tree Hill too. Us fans know what we are talking about, clearly.

Posted Image

Other highlights are another brilliantly performed track on 360, The Unforgettable Fire. UF segues perfectly into the next track, Zooropa, despite never being played together and being played two years apart on two different continents! Big tick here, especially when City of Blinding Lights follows almost seamlessly. Remarkably, the track placement ebbs and flows in a manner that makes it still feel like a cohesive concert. We are however reminded that it is not when the crowd chants the Pride coda in the Zagreb tribute to Aung San Suu Kyi despite Pride not being played. A perfect version of MLK into Walk On follows to distract us from this. The Unforgettable Fire album does very well on this release, as it did on the tour. Also we can't forget to mention Ultraviolet, a 360 theme song of sorts, sounding fantastic on the back of Where The Streets Have No Name - no easy feat! I personally miss earlier versions of With or Without You but, no matter how it is played, it still sounds great and always will. Probably should always be after Ultraviolet too!

Although not surprised that I'll Go Crazy If I Don't Go Crazy Tonight wasn't selected (I didn't vote for it either), a 360 collection sounds strange without it. It makes it a relief that Moment of Surrender, another key track of 360, is included. Reflective and moody, just like the end of a U2 concert should be. Think Red Rocks. Think Zoo TV live in Sydney. But of course, we are fans and we ALWAYS want one more. So we voted for Out of Control, didn't we? Because we know, don't we?

In the end, what makes this special is that we got a chance to have input. And sure, not everyone's selections will have made it. I'm still crying about NLOTH not being included and where was Acrobat? But the ones that did get selected sound great. The fact that it is largely cohesive and as good a live compilation as you will hear is because we picked it and U2 played it. I just listened to One again. I don't know what I was worried about.


Rxx
Sep 01 2012 01:28 PM
Great review Wes, I guess this will bring up the whole U2.com subscription question for people, although after reading this : http://www.atu2.com/...a-new-name.html - from @U2 that may just swing it?

Wendynz
Sep 02 2012 08:12 AM
Thanks for the review Wes. I am still waiting patiently to receive U22. The last email I got from U2.com said it was being sent on August 13th....I guess I will have to contact them again.

Wes
Sep 02 2012 12:06 PM
Hi Wendy- Thanks. I think around 20 days postage to NZ is about right. If it doesn't come this week can you let us know andwe will chase up too.

Wendynz
Sep 09 2012 06:37 AM
Well Wes it still haven't got it and I have had no answer from U2.com...

Wes
Sep 11 2012 02:59 PM
Wendy- can you msg me the details and we will if we can get some traction.

Cheers

Rxx
Sep 14 2012 08:28 PM
Wendy - I subscribed on 6th Sept and received mine today, 14th Sept - I'd definately chase yours up (haven't opened it yet!).

Wendynz
Sep 15 2012 07:27 AM
I have sent numerous emails. I have finally received a reply saying they were just processing my cd for shipment now...that was on 12th September with no explanation as to whether this was the first time it was shipped or whether mine has got lost in the post. So given the time it took for yours to arrive hopefully I will posting that mine has arrived on the 22nd September.

Wendynz
Sep 20 2012 06:07 PM
I have finally received the pack today. I also received an email that they were sorry for the delay as they had received a lot of emails in the last few weeks. I replied stating that maybe they would have less work following up on shipping queries if they reorgainised their dispatching system so that orders that were placed first were also shipped first....

Rxx
Nov 22 2012 06:15 AM
Keep meaning to post - I love that One Tree Hill from Auckland is on there, BUT, anyone else think it just hasn't quite got the atmosphere that it has from watching the various You Tube videos, lots of the other tracks have the crowd up LOUD and I know it was a small venue but there were moments when the crowd joined in and it's just not on the track - plus hands up everyone who says Bono's bits "a little more light Willie" and "Beautiful etc... ;)

And as far as the dispatch system - surely they should be saying they dispatch to renewing members first and then new members seeing as I got mine within a few days - goodness knows how the book for this years membership will fare.